Al in Healthcare: From Hype to Hope

Artificial Intelligence (AI) continues to be the talk of any strategic conversations in healthcare, yet many hospital leaders are left wondering: When are we going to derive tangible results?

Numerous AI technologies are currently navigating the 'Trough of Disillusionment'- a phase where inflated expectations give way to real-world complexity. Healthcare, more than most sectors, reveals this dual reality distinctly. Some applications are beginning to show real value, while others still struggle under the weight of a high cost-to-value ratio or lack of adaptation.

The Hype: Where Al Is Still Underperforming in Healthcare

There are many use cases in healthcare that were once the flagbearers of AI success that are now proving difficult to scale or generalize, some of the common ones are listed below:

Clinical Decision Support Systems (CDSS) often rely on narrow datasets that are not representative of the Indian clinical diversity. This results in adoption challenges and clinician pushback due to the "black-box" nature of these models. Moreover, limited real-time integration with existing Hospital Information Systems (HIS) or Electronic Medical Records (EMR) remains a significant hurdle.

AI Tools for Radiology Reporting face performance drops as the models are not fully trained with Indian datasets. They show inconsistent success across different geographies and often lack compatibility with fully DICOM image formats. Additionally, regulatory ambiguity and a lack of clinical trust continue to pose challenges for their widespread use.

Hospital operational efficiency gain by Resource Optimization also faces issues. Predictive models often fail due to poor workflow adherence or incomplete data availability. Furthermore, these solutions can cause workflow disruptions since they are not co-developed with clinical or administrative teams and often do not align well with existing workflow processes.

The Hope: Where AI Is Delivering Value and Creating Real Impact

Yet, not all is an eyewash, as there are a good number of success stories as well. Several AI applications have transitioned from pilot to constructive usage.

AI-Enabled Eye Screening has shown a significant impact on diabetic retinopathy screening, particularly in rural India. A notable success story is the collaboration between Aravind Eye Care and Google AI, which enabled early detection using a low-cost, smartphone-based camera. This solution facilitated triaging at the point of care and reduced referrals by as much as 50%.

Cardiac Risk Prediction is being applied for proactive heart health assessments. An example of this is the partnership between Apollo Hospitals and Microsoft, where AI models evaluated risk factors using Electronic Health Records (EHR) and lifestyle parameters. This approach enabled early lifestyle intervention and timely follow-up.

Tuberculosis Screening with Chest X-rays is being used for large-scale TB screening in community settings. Tools such as CAD4TB and Qure.ai’s qXR have been employed, with automated X-ray interpretation by AI significantly improving diagnosis access. These solutions have already been scaled across government and many NGO-based screening programs.

Administrative AI Applications are also gaining traction in healthcare settings. Amrita Hospitals, for example, uses a range of AI tools for administrative tasks. These include a chatbot for patient appointment booking, voice-based transcription of clinical notes, and AI-driven scheduling of OT slots.

For C-Suite Leaders: 5 Strategic Insights

1. AI is not going to replace doctors; it is ready to assist them. Augmentation is the true value proposition, so doctors can be more efficient and productive with the use of AI tools.

2. Start with operations before diagnostics. Administrative AI applications often deliver quicker ROI and face fewer challenges in user adoption, due to the ‘black-box’ nature of AI.

3. Many AI initiatives fail to scale, even after successful PoC (Proof of Concepts). Ensure the variations across departments can be accommodated, and buy-in across departments is very critical, so engage well with your stakeholders.

4. Invest in infrastructure and data security. No AI is more important than the protection of your data. EMR adoption and interoperability are non-negotiables, so performance and accessibility are important.

5. Choose contextual models over universal AI applications as AI models trained in Western data sets need not suit Indian clinical settings, so they have to be possibly retrained and configured.

Looking Ahead: From Disillusionment to Empowerment

Technological maturity is a long journey, and it's very important to understand and gauge where and at which stage we are at. AI in healthcare is slowly but surely moving from hype to hope, but only when we approach it with realism, rigor, and responsibility. Healthcare services are determined by 4 pillars - Accessibility, Affordability, Appropriateness, and Accuracy, and AI has a good, promising fitment for each one of these 4 pillars.

India, with its vast patient base and growing digital health ecosystem driven by the policy laid out by the Government (Ayushman Bharat Digital Mission, eSanjeevani, NDHM, etc.), is uniquely positioned to build scalable, inclusive, and frugal AI health solutions. Let us move forward, not with inflated expectations, but with informed conviction and rigorous commitment.

Stay tuned for more such updates on Digital Health News